The Fair Education Alliance welcomes Alan Milburn's final report. It confirms what we and our members have long known to be true: young people are not the problem. They have been let down by a system that has failed to provide the support and opportunities they need. We’re especially pleased to see that youth engagement has been such a strong strand of the Review’s work, and that young people’s voices are central in the Review’s findings.
The Review calls for a complete reset of how young people are prepared for and supported to enter the world of work. This is the right response, and if the government takes just one thing from this report, it should be the report's finding that poverty and inequality are at the core of the NEET crisis. Young people who have been eligible for free school meals are twice as likely to become NEET. We hope the government factors in the powerful role that poverty plays when it formulates its response. With targeted support for those most in need, we have the best chance of ensuring that no young person falls through the cracks.
Put great teachers and broader learning where disadvantage is greatest
We're pleased to see calls to focus recruitment and retention efforts on the most disadvantaged communities. This matches a recommendation in our Report Card 2026 to support underserved communities to recruit school staff from and for their local areas. Recent improvements in teacher recruitment have been encouraging, but not all parts of the country face equal challenges: we know recruiting and retaining teachers is harder for schools in low-income areas.
We're encouraged by the Review's proposals to broaden the curriculum, raise the status of technical routes, judge schools on destinations as well as grades, and join up education, skills and employment. To deliver on them, young people from low-income households must be a distinct priority group in local plans, and Vocational GCSEs must widen choices, not stream pupils. We also welcome the Review's call to consider raising the Early Years Pupil Premium to match the primary school rate, as we called for in our Report Card 2024. And we warmly welcome the recommendation to expand Family Hubs in the areas of highest disadvantage, with more capacity for local authorities and Mayoral Strategic Authorities (MSAs) to join up services for very young children.
Judge schools fairly on where pupils go next
The Review's proposed ready-for-work standard and new destination measure could correct an imbalance in existing accountability measures. The FEA has previously called for schools to be recognised for where their young people go next, not only for their exam results. We especially welcome the recommendation that destination measures take account of pupils' starting points, socio-economic circumstances and place. Schools serving low-income communities must be judged on the progress they enable, not the advantages their pupils lack. That principle must apply to the ready-for-work rate too. These measures should be designed with school leaders, use data schools already hold, and come with support rather than new workload. Schools cannot be held accountable for local opportunities they don't control. The Youth Opportunity Service, employers and MSAs must share responsibility for work experience and progression.
Devolution needs money and capacity, not just powers
The Review proposes that strategic authorities, led by mayors where they exist, take charge of a joined-up participation system for 16 to 24 year-olds. It would be delivered through a new Youth Opportunity Service, working with councils, schools, colleges, the NHS and employers. This matches the FEA's call for national, regional and local government to work together around every child. But devolution is not just about powers. MSAs also need sustained funding and the capacity to use it. Many are new, and councils' children's and youth services are highly stretched. The Review's commitment to multi-year Participation Agreements is right. Places with the highest NEET rates must be resourced first, so that no young person gets a weaker offer because of where they live.
Disadvantage doesn't stop at 16 – nor should the funding
The Review calls for colleges to receive a new participation and work-readiness premium, initially targeted at 16 and 17 year-olds who were previously NEET or at serious risk of becoming NEET. We have consistently called for a 16–19 Student Premium, because education continues past 16 but disadvantage funding does not. We would like to see this premium targeted at young people from low-income households, and designed to support academic attainment as well as participation and work readiness. The Review's recommendation would be a positive step forward, but it could go further by ensuring the funding can help young people gain the qualifications they need to unlock their next steps.
Support should follow need, not a diagnosis
We have advocated for preventative, whole-school inclusion that sees most young people's needs met without a formal diagnosis. We are pleased to see the Review call for a very similar approach. A needs-led system would mean young people do not have to wait for a diagnosis to unlock the support they need. This will push the system towards earlier support, improving engagement and the chances of a positive destination in education, employment or training. It could be strengthened by accelerating steps towards a national pupil wellbeing measurement programme, as called for by Our Wellbeing Our Voice. Without such a measure, schools, colleges, local authorities, MSAs and government will continue to operate without an accurate picture of young people's wellbeing.
Prepare young people for a working world reshaped by AI
We welcome the Review's recognition that AI could erode the entry-level jobs through which young people have traditionally learned how to work. We also welcome its proposals for AI skills training for every young person and a new AI Youth Observatory to track how entry routes are changing. But these sit largely apart from the Review's education reforms. Our forthcoming Jobs for Tomorrow thematic partnership, and the AI golden thread running through our strategy, reflect the need to rethink how we educate and prepare young people for a rapidly changing world of work. We hope the government's response will give deeper consideration to how fundamentally AI could change the labour market for young people, and what that means for schools and colleges.
A guarantee is only as good as the offer behind it
We welcome the proposal to put a Young People's Guarantee into law, an entitlement to both opportunity and support. Too many youth programmes have come and gone. A statutory guarantee could finally give young people something they can rely on. To deliver for those who need it most, there must be quality opportunities in every area, not just where provision already exists. The guarantee must be properly funded, so that the right to an offer means a good offer wherever a young person lives.
Opportunity first, obligations second
The Review's recommendations on welfare are likely to be its most contested. It proposes replacing Universal Credit for young people with a single Youth Allowance, abolishing the health element and the Work Capability Assessment, and replacing Personal Independence Payment (PIP) with a new Additional Cost Allowance. Alongside these sit a statutory Opportunity Guarantee and Support Guarantee, and a new duty to engage. We agree that upfront investment in opportunities and support must come first for young people currently receiving benefits. More than seven in ten young people who are NEET want a job or training, but too many are denied the opportunity. The funding must be front-loaded to support them.
We would be concerned if welfare funding were withdrawn or reduced without prior support, or where there are few realistic training and work opportunities. Reciprocity is right when there are meaningful opportunities for young people. Obligations should follow a high-quality offer and practical help (travel, equipment, a trusted adult). The Review is right that sanctions should be rare, and they must not push young people from the lowest-income households further away.
We believe young people's voices should be central to the government's consideration of these changes. For young people, especially those with disabilities, PIP and other benefits can be a lifeline that helps them into work or to make ends meet in tough times. It is essential that these lived experiences shape new welfare policy in response to this Review.
The system failed young people – now it must deliver for them
Alan Milburn is right: young people haven't failed – the system has. This report sets out a blueprint ambitious enough to fix it. The test now is whether it reaches the young people facing the biggest barriers, and whether government gives local partners the time, data and funding to work together. Our members are ready to help make that happen.
We urge the government to prioritise three principles in its response:
Design every measure around young people from the lowest-income households and those who have faced other barriers to learning, informed by meaningful youth engagement.
Invest in the partnerships that make joined-up support real: time, data, people and shared governance.
Start earlier, with schools as full partners in prevention and Family Hubs rolled out further in areas of high disadvantage.
Many of our member organisations, and our place-based collaborations with the Liverpool City Region Combined Authority, South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority and West Midlands Combined Authority, are leading the way through deep partnership working, but more support from government is needed to make this work sustainable in the long-term. We would welcome the chance to work with the DWP, DfE, No.10 and the Youth Opportunity Team to turn these recommendations into effective delivery.